NEW YEAR’S EVE
2026!
Featuring America’s Top Headliners
SOLD OUT!
People come again and again to spend New Year’s Eve at the Comedy Cellar, and for good reason: From our spectacular show, to our synchronized countdown, and our over-the-top festive decorations, we truly go all out to make sure that you have a great time.
12/31/2025 SHOWS:
Click to jump to
We will be ringing in 2026 in the course of these shows with a Champagne Toast at Midnight!
SOLD OUT!
8.00pm
at The Comedy Cellar Show
(117 MacDougal St Entrance)
Your Host:
Jon Laster – The Winner of Stand up NBC
Dan Naturman – From HBO’s Crashing, The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, Last Comic Standing
Emma Willmann: From The Late Show with Stephen Colbert, MTV, VH1
Andy Haynes – From The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, Conan, Comedy Central Presents
Rosebud Baker – Netflix Special The Mother Lode, Comedy Central Special Whiskey Fists
Lenny Marcus – From The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, The David Letterman Show
Peter Revello – From The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, Comedy Central
$40.00 + $15.00 service bonus.
Line-up subject to change (cancellations are a rare occurrence) however the quality always remains the same.
SOLD OUT!
8.01pm
at The Village Underground Show
(130 W 3rd St Entrance)
Your Host:
Ray Ellin – Star of Late Net with Ray Ellin, Gong Show Live, Fox’s Red Eye, Comedy Central
Rachel Feinstein – From her Netflix special Big Guy, From the movie Trainwreck, guest co-host on The View
Lenny Marcus – From The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, The David Letterman Show
Jim Norton – From The Late Show with David Letterman, Lucky Louie, The Opie and Anthony Show, The Jim and Sam Show
Keith Robinson – From HBO’s Crashing, Trainwreck, Back of the Bus Funny, Comedy Central’s Tough Crowd, Different Strokes on Netflix
Dave Attell – From Insomniac with Dave Attell, The David Letterman Show, Dave’s Old Porn, Tough Crowd
Drew Dunn – From The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, Winner of Boston and Seattle Comedy Festivals
+ Live music playing the acts on
and off stage
$40.00 + $15.00 service bonus.
Line-up subject to change (cancellations are a rare occurrence) however the quality always remains the same.
SOLD OUT!
8.30pm
The Fat Black Pussycat (BAR) Show
(130 W 3rd St Entrance)
Your Host:
Matt Richards – From HQ Trivia, Two Broke Girls, That Damn Michael Che Show
Wil Sylvince – From Showtime, HBO, Shortcuts Film Festival
Yamaneika Saunders – From The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, Netflix’s The Degenerates, Life and Beth
Nathan Macintosh – From his special Down with Tech, Variety’s Ten Comics to Watch List 2024
Aminah Imani – From Just for Laughs New Faces, Inside Amy Schumer, Flatbush Misdemeanors
Jamie Wolf – Timeout Magazine 2025 Comic to Watch, Winner NY’s Funniest 2024
$40.00 + $15.00 service bonus.
Line-up subject to change (cancellations are a rare occurrence) however the quality always remains the same.
SOLD OUT!
8.31pm
The Fat Black Pussycat (LOUNGE) Show
(130 W 3rd St Entrance)
Your Host:
Eric Neumann – From The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, Netflix, Comedy Central, IFC
Mike Feeney – From The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon
Lynne Koplitz – Netflix special Hormonal Beast, Joan and Melissa Rivers’ reality show Joan Knows Best
Gregg Rogell – From Louie, The Aristocrats, The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, Comedy Central’s Tough Crowd
Jourdain Fisher – From Comedy Central, The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, BET, NBC
Allan Havey – From Mad Men, The Office, Billions, Crashing, Curb Your Enthusiasm
Godfrey – From Louie, 30 Rock, Soul Plane, Host of the podcast In Godfrey We Trust
$40.00 + $15.00 service bonus.
Line-up subject to change (cancellations are a rare occurrence) however the quality always remains the same.
SOLD OUT!
10.00pm
at The Comedy Cellar Show
(117 MacDougal St Entrance)
We will be ringing in 2026 in the course of this show!
Champagne Toast at Midnight!
Your Host:
Jon Laster – The Winner of Stand up NBC
Regina DeCicco – Warm Up Comic for The View, Sirius XM, AXS-TV
Jourdain Fisher – From Comedy Central, The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, BET, NBC
Jim Norton – From The Late Show with David Letterman, Lucky Louie, The Opie and Anthony Show, The Jim and Sam Show
Keith Robinson – From HBO’s Crashing, Trainwreck, Back of the Bus Funny, Comedy Central’s Tough Crowd, Different Strokes on Netflix
Drew Dunn – From The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, Winner of Boston and Seattle Comedy Festivals
Dave Attell – From Insomniac with Dave Attell, The David Letterman Show, Dave’s Old Porn, Tough Crowd
Caitlin Peluffo – From The Late Late Show, The Late Show with Stephen Colbert
Rick Crom – From The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, Inside Amy Schumer, Louie
$80.00 + $15.00 service bonus.
Line-up subject to change (cancellations are a rare occurrence) however the quality always remains the same.
SOLD OUT!
10.01pm
at The Village Underground Show
(130 W 3rd St Entrance)
We will be ringing in 2026 in the course of this show!
Champagne Toast at Midnight!
Your Host:
Ardie Fuqua – From The Louie CK Show, Tough Crowd
Andy Haynes – From The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, Conan, Comedy Central Presents
Gregg Rogell – From Louie, The Aristocrats, The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, Comedy Central’s Tough Crowd
Lynne Koplitz – Netflix special Hormonal Beast, Joan and Melissa Rivers’ reality show Joan Knows Best
Peter Revello – From The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, Comedy Central
Dave Attell – From Insomniac with Dave Attell, The David Letterman Show, Dave’s Old Porn, Tough Crowd
Rosebud Baker – Netflix Special The Mother Lode, Comedy Central Special Whiskey Fists
Godfrey – From Louie, 30 Rock, Soul Plane, Host of the podcast In Godfrey We Trust
+ Live music playing the acts on
and off stage
$80.00 + $15.00 service bonus.
Line-up subject to change (cancellations are a rare occurrence) however the quality always remains the same.
SOLD OUT!
10.30pm
The Fat Black Pussycat (BAR) Show
(130 W 3rd St Entrance)
We will be ringing in 2026 in the course of this show!
Champagne Toast at Midnight!
Your Host:
Mike Yard – From The Nightly Show with Larry Wilmore, Bad Boys of Comedy, Def Comedy Jam
Mike Feeney – From The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon
Emma Willmann – From The Late Show with Stephen Colbert, MTV, VH1
Allan Havey – From Mad Men, The Office, Billions, Crashing, Curb Your Enthusiasm
Regina DeCicco – Warm Up Comic for The View, Sirius XM, AXS-TV
Aminah Imani – From Just for Laughs New Faces, Inside Amy Schumer, Flatbush Misdemeanors
Matt Richards – From HQ Trivia, Two Broke Girls, That Damn Michael Che Show
$80.00 + $15.00 service bonus.
Line-up subject to change (cancellations are a rare occurrence) however the quality always remains the same.
SOLD OUT!
10.31pm
The Fat Black Pussycat (LOUNGE) Show
(130 W 3rd St Entrance)
We will be ringing in 2026 in the course of this show!
Champagne Toast at Midnight!
Your Host:
Wil Sylvince – From Showtime, HBO, Shortcuts Film Festival
Jamie Wolf – Timeout Magazine 2025 Comic to Watch, Winner NY’s Funniest 2024
Rachel Feinstein – From her Netflix special Big Guy, From the movie Trainwreck, guest co-host on The View
Dan Naturman – From HBO’s Crashing, The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, Last Comic Standing
Yamaneika Saunders – From The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, Netflix’s The Degenerates, Life and Beth
Drew Dunn – From The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, Winner of Boston and Seattle Comedy Festivals
$80.00 + $15.00 service bonus.
Line-up subject to change (cancellations are a rare occurrence) however the quality always remains the same.
If you would like to pay in person, or you have ANY QUESTIONS at all, PLEASE email us at NewYear@ComedyCellar.com, or call us at 212-254-3480.
We have a fantastic dinner and drink menu to choose from:
> Comedy Cellar Menu
> Village Underground Menu
> Fat Black Pussycat Menu
Admission is 21 and over.
You are buying tickets for 12/31/2025
$15.00 of each ticket goes directly to your server as a service bonus – please tip on your food and drinks 🙂
PRICES:
Early Shows – $40.00 cover charge + $15.00 service bonus for your server. 2 item food or drink minimum per person.
Late (Ring in the New Year) Shows – $80.00 cover charge +$15.00 service bonus for your server. 2 item food or drink minimum per person.
Why a Service Bonus? New Year’s Eve is a very difficult night for our servers. They spend a 12 hour day decorating and setting up, and because there are fewer shows, they often go home with less than a normal night 🙁
Other clubs charge a processing fee just to buy tickets online – it’s really just a way of raising the ticket price. But the truth is that there is virtually no extra cost for us to sell tickets online.
THEREFORE, We charge no processing fee to buy our tickets. Our service bonus goes directly to your server. It’s their safety-net for the night. We hope that in the holiday spirit you’ll still tip generously on your food and drinks.
See Pics of our new Fat Black Pussycat rooms (directly above the Village Underground). Rooms are equal in size and seat around 75 each.
See Map:
117 MacDougal St Entrance:
– Comedy Cellar & Olive Tree Cafe
130 W 3rd St Entrance:
– The Village Underground
– Fat Black Pussy Cat (Bar)
– Fat Black Pussy Cat (Lounge)
Enjoy our latest clips and discover unseen gems from our archive!
